blogs
How to Know When It's Time to Invest in an ATS: Key Indicators to Look For

MyNextHire | October 9, 2024

As your business grows, so do your recruitment challenges. Whether you’re struggling with an overwhelming number of job applications or a frustratingly long time-to-hire, there comes a point when manual recruitment processes just aren’t cutting it anymore. That's when you start asking the big question:Is it time to invest in an Applicant Tracking System (ATS)?
In this blog, we'll explore the key indicators that signal it's time to make the leap from manual recruitment to an ATS—specifically,MyNext Hire, a cutting-edge ATS designed to help businesses scale efficiently while improving candidate quality. Understanding these signs will help you streamline your recruitment process and set your company up for long-term success.

1. Your Hiring Needs Are Growing Faster Than You Can Keep Up

One of the clearest signs that your company needs an ATS like MyNextHire is when your hiring demands are outpacing your team’s capacity. If your company is growing rapidly and you’re hiring for multiple roles at once, managing everything manually—tracking applicants in spreadsheets, manually scheduling interviews, or posting job ads on various platforms—can quickly become unmanageable.

Indicators You’re Facing Growing Hiring Needs:
  • Multiple open positions that your team is struggling to fill simultaneously.
  • Frequent job postings across different departments.
  • A growing number of applications making it difficult to keep track of candidates.
  • Recruitment teams feeling overworked or unable to prioritize tasks effectively.

MyNextHire can help you automate and organize your recruitment process, making it easier to keep up with increasing demands without overwhelming your HR team.

2. You’re Missing Out on Top Talent Due to a Lengthy Hiring Process

Are your ideal candidates dropping out halfway through the recruitment process? Or are they being snatched up by competitors before you’ve had a chance to extend an offer? If this sounds familiar, you might have a time-to-hire problem.
A long, drawn-out hiring process can not only frustrate candidates but also result in missed opportunities. The best candidates are often off the market within a matter of days or weeks, and if your hiring process drags on, they’ll likely accept offers elsewhere.

Indicators of Time-to-Hire Issues:
  • A time-to-hire that exceeds industry benchmarks (e.g., more than 30 days for most roles).
  • Top candidates frequently drop out before completing the interview process.
  • Delayed hiring decisions leave teams understaffed, impacting productivity.
  • Offers are extended too late, and candidates accept other job offers.

MyNextHire can significantly speed up your recruitment process by automating time-consuming tasks like resume screening and interview scheduling. With MyNextHire, you can keep candidates engaged, make faster decisions, and avoid losing top talent to your competitors.

3. You Struggle with Tracking and Organizing Candidate Data

Without an ATS, recruitment teams often rely on a mix of spreadsheets, email chains, and paper documents to track applicants. While this might work when you’re hiring for one or two roles, things can quickly spiral out of control as your hiring needs increase. If you’re losing track of candidate information, missing follow-ups, or forgetting to schedule interviews, it’s time for an upgrade.

Signs You Need Better Candidate Tracking:
  • Candidate resumes, interview notes, and feedback are scattered across multiple platforms or documents.
  • It’s hard to track where each candidate is in the recruitment pipeline.
  • You’re missing deadlines to follow up with candidates, leading to poor communication and candidate experience.
  • Team members struggle to collaborate or share feedback on candidates.

MyNextHire provides a centralized databasewhere all candidate information is stored and easily accessible by recruiters, hiring managers, and team members. It also provides clear visibility into where each candidate stands in the hiring process, ensuring that nothing slips through the cracks.

4. You Lack Automation and Are Bogged Down by Manual Tasks

Manual recruitment tasks can quickly eat up your team’s time and energy, leaving them with little room for more strategic activities like interviewing candidates or building relationships. If your recruiters are still manually screening resumes, scheduling interviews, or sending follow-up emails, it's time to consider MyNextHire.

Signs You Need Automation:
  • Your recruiters are spending too much time on repetitive tasks like scheduling interviews or sorting resumes.
  • Key steps in your hiring process are delayed because of manual interventions.
  • Candidate communication is inconsistent, and many applicants are left in the dark.
  • Your team doesn’t have the bandwidth to focus on high-value tasks like building relationships with candidates or developing long-term recruitment strategies.

MyNextHire allows you to automate repetitive tasks, freeing up time for your recruitment team to focus on more strategic efforts. From resume screening to sending automated follow-ups, MyNextHire streamlines these processes, improving efficiency and reducing the risk of errors.

5. You’re Facing High Turnover or Poor Quality of Hires

If you’re consistently hiring people who don’t last long or who aren’t a good fit for your company, the issue might be your recruitment process. Relying on manual screening can result in poor-quality hires, leading to higher turnover rates and more time spent re-hiring for the same roles.

Indicators of Poor Hiring Quality:
  • A high turnover rate, with new hires leaving the company within the first year.
  • Low employee satisfaction or engagement due to mismatches in company culture or job expectations.
  • Constantly having to re-hire for the same positions because of bad fits.

MyNextHire can help you improve the quality of your hires by automating the screening process and using advancedAI-driven matching to ensure that candidates meet not only the technical requirements but also align with your company’s values and culture. With MyNextHire, you can make more informed decisions that lead to longer employee retention and higher job satisfaction.

6. You’re Struggling to Scale Your Recruitment Efforts

As your company grows, your recruitment process needs to scale with it. Manual processes might work for small businesses with a handful of roles to fill, but they don’t provide the scalability needed to handle an expanding team and a rapidly growing number of candidates.

Signs You Need Scalability:
  • Your company is expanding, and hiring needs are increasing.
  • You’re planning to open new locations, departments, or roles that require ongoing recruitment.
  • Your current recruitment process can’t keep up with increased demands.

MyNextHire is built to scale with your company, allowing you to manage a larger volume of applications without sacrificing efficiency or candidate experience. The system grows as your business grows, ensuring that your recruitment process remains seamless and organized.

Is It Time to Invest in MyNextHire?

If any of these signs resonate with your company’s current recruitment challenges, it might be time to consider investing in MyNextHire. From automating manual tasks to improving candidate quality and helping your recruitment efforts scale, MyNextHire can revolutionize the way your business hires.

Increase Your Hiring Efficiency by 30% in 4 weeks!

Want to talk to One of the MyNextHire SMEs to find out how?
Schedule a Free Demo